Growth is not marketing
More marketing into an app that loses people is a leaky bucket. How to find the hole where your users give up, and why patching it beats pouring in more.

·5 min read
On this page
When an app stops growing, most people reach for more marketing. More posts, more ads, a bigger launch.
Usually that's the wrong fix. Here's why, and how to find the right one.
The short version
Pouring more marketing into an app that loses people after they download it is like filling a leaky bucket. You keep pouring, and it keeps running out the holes.
Before you pour in more, find the biggest hole: the point where most people give up on your app. Patch that first.

The hole I almost missed
I built Prospect Ping, an app for baseball fans who follow minor league prospects. You pick the players you care about, and it sends you an alert when they're in the lineup, at bat or pitching. I've never paid for a single user.
I assumed the next step was getting more people to find it. Then I checked the numbers. About one in five people who signed up had never followed a single player.
Without a player to follow, the app has nothing to send you. Those people downloaded it and got nothing. They were never going to come back or tell a friend. More marketing would have poured more people into the same hole.
Growth is a chain
Every app grows through the same five steps. Each one feeds the next.
| Step | The question | If it's weak |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Find | How do people hear about it? | Nobody shows up |
| 2. Aha moment | Do they reach the moment the app proves its worth? | They leave before it clicks |
| 3. Come back | Does it become a habit? | They try it once and forget it |
| 4. Share | Do users bring in new users? | Every new user costs you effort |
| 5. Pay | Does it earn money to reinvest? | You can't afford to grow faster |
Marketing is step 1. Steps 2 to 5 all happen inside your product. That's what "growth is not marketing" means: marketing is one link, not the whole chain.
Why patching the hole beats more marketing
The aha moment is the first time your app proves it's worth keeping. For Prospect Ping, it's the first alert about a player you actually care about.
Say 1,000 people download your app each month and 20% of them reach that moment. That's 200 people who actually got value.
You have two ways to double it:
- Double your marketing. 2,000 people download it, 20% reach the aha moment: 400 people. You have to keep paying for that extra reach every month.
- Patch the hole. The same 1,000 people download it, but now 40% reach the aha moment: 400 people. You fix it once and it keeps working.

Same result this month. But patching wins, for a reason most people miss: it makes all your future marketing work twice as hard. Every person you bring in from now on is twice as likely to reach the aha moment, and so to come back and tell a friend. More marketing without patching just pours more people into the same holes.
Sean Ellis saw this at LogMeIn, where he led growth. They raised the share of new users who reached the aha moment from about 5% to 50% in three months. That's what let their paid campaigns scale, and word of mouth picked up with it. The fix was in the product, and it made the marketing work better.
The step nobody owns
The aha moment is the hole people ignore most. Ellis explains why: at most companies, marketing brings people to the door, and the product team improves things for the people already inside. Nobody owns the moment in between, where a new person either sees what they were promised or leaves.
If you build alone, you own that moment. Nobody else is going to fix it.
Find your biggest hole
Write down one number for each step. Rough is fine.
- Find: how many people downloaded or signed up last month.
- Aha moment: what percent did the one thing your app is for. For Prospect Ping, that's following a player.
- Come back: what percent were back a week later.
- Share: how many invited or told someone.
- Pay: what percent pay.
Your biggest hole is usually the step where the number drops the most. To check, ask Ellis's question: if this step doubled, what would happen to everything after it? The step with the biggest answer is the one to patch.
Then try one small fix at a time and write down what you learned.
If you’re struggling to choose what to fix first, tell me about your app: where it is, your numbers and what’s in the way.
Three things this doesn't mean
1. Marketing doesn't matter. It does. If nobody finds your app, you can't learn anything about the other steps. This is about order, not either/or.
2. Fix everything at once. One hole at a time. You can't tell what worked if you change five things together.
3. A good funnel saves any app. Ellis checks one thing before all of this: would anyone be upset if the app disappeared? If the answer is no, the whole bucket leaks, and the fix is the app itself.
Want to go deeper?
Sean Ellis, who coined the term "growth hacking" and led early growth at Dropbox and LogMeIn, wrote one of the clearest explanations of this idea I've read: Why Systems Thinking Matters for Startup Growth. It's written for startup teams, but the way he explains it works just as well for one person and one app.
This week: write down your five numbers, find your biggest hole, and patch only that.
Get better at growing apps.
New case studies and guides on how apps grow. Free, straight to your inbox.

Written by Matt Neves
I study how apps grow and break down the case studies for 20,000+ app builders as @agenticmatt. I test what I learn on my own apps.
More about meKeep reading

Acquisition · 5 min read
How to grow your app with no budget
Ads rent people's attention. Dropbox, Gymshark and Tinder borrowed it for free. The three places to borrow attention for your app, and how to start this week.

Growth loops · 7 min read
Pick the referral program that fits your app
Nobody shares an app to save 10%. How Harry's, Morning Brew and Robinhood got people sharing with rewards money can't buy, how to pick yours, and a prompt that designs it.

Acquisition · 2 min read
Find your first users with AI
Your first users are already posting about the problem your app solves. An AI research prompt that finds those threads and groups, and how to show up without spamming.